The rise of digital technology along with bringing convenience and connectivity, has also exposed several vulnerable populations, especially seniors to increasingly sophisticated fraud schemes. In Ontario, financial scams targeting the elderly have become alarmingly prevalent, often leaving victims not only financially devastated but also emotionally distressed. As elder law continues to evolve, it is crucial for legal professionals working in elder law and families to be aware of both the growing risks and the legal remedies available to protect vulnerable seniors from exploitation.

Digital Exploitation of Seniors: A Case Study from Sarnia

In a stark example of the financial exploitation of the elderly, recent reports from Sarnia indicate that three seniors lost over $1 million collectively in separate online frauds. Each of these victims was over the age of 60, underscoring the particular vulnerability of older adults to such schemes. The reported scams ranged from romance fraud to prize scams, where perpetrators manipulated seniors over an extended period, gaining their trust before requesting large sums of money under false pretenses.

In one instance, a 67-year-old woman was deceived by a fraudster posing as a physician with Doctors Without Borders, who after a year of building a fake online relationship, convinced her to provide him financial assistance to evacuate from a war zone, ultimately scamming her out of over $350,000. Another senior, a 66-year-old man, fell victim to a combination of romance and lottery scams, resulting in a total loss of $710,000. Despite the magnitude of these losses, police emphasize that this type of fraud is increasingly common and challenging to investigate, as scammers often operate from outside the country.[1]

Door-to-Door Fraud: Ontario’s Legal Response

In addition to online scams, door-to-door fraud schemes have also heavily targeted seniors. Ontario Provincial Police recently uncovered a large-scale door-to-door sales fraud operation that defrauded over 200 older residents across the province. The scammers coerced seniors into signing contracts for fraudulent products and services, leading to significant financial losses.

As part of the legal recourse, the newly passed Bill 200 from June 2024, the Homeowner Protection Act[2] and the previously existing Consumer Protection Act[3] of 2002 provide crucial safeguards for seniors. Under the Homeowner Protection Act, any Notice of Security Interest (NOSI) registered before June 6, 2024, is deemed expired, and seniors can apply through a lawyer to have these expired notices removed. Moreover, the Consumer Protection Act offers a “cooling off” period that allows individuals to cancel contracts signed under duress or misrepresentation within 10 days. If a business misrepresents a product or service, victims are entitled to a full refund if they withdraw from the contract within one year.[4]

The “Grandparent Scam”: Legal Accountability and Sentencing

Another common form of elder exploitation involves the notorious “grandparent scam,” where fraudsters impersonate a grandchild in distress to manipulate seniors into handing over money. Recently, two Ontario women were sentenced for their involvement in a grandparent scam that scammed several elderly in Manitoba of nearly $90,000. The perpetrators acted as “money mules,” collecting cash from the homes of their elderly victims, who believed they were bailing their grandchildren out of jail.

While these scammers were sentenced to conditional sentences and probation, the broader operation underscores the need for more robust legal frameworks to address the root of such fraudulent schemes. Prosecutors highlighted how these schemes often involve complex networks, with the most sophisticated fraudsters remaining isolated from the direct financial transaction, leaving those on the ground to face the legal consequences.[5]

The surge in financial scams targeting seniors highlights a troubling trend of manipulation and exploitation. From online fraud to door-to-door schemes, elderly individuals continue to fall prey to criminals who exploit their trust and vulnerability. The emotional and financial toll these scams take is profound, leaving many victims devastated and unsure of where to turn. As these cases show, it’s essential for seniors and their families to stay informed and cautious to protect themselves from falling victim to these increasingly sophisticated schemes.

—

[1] Morden, Paul, Londoner: Local News “ Sarnia seniors taken for $1M+ in separate online scams: city police”, online : <https://www.thelondoner.ca/news/local-news/sarnia-seniors-taken-for-1m-in-separate-online-scams-city-police>

[2] Homeowner Protection Act, 2024, SO 2024, C 18, <https://www.ontario.ca/files/s3fs-public/2024-06/bulletin_2024-07_homeowner_protection_act.pdf>

[3] Consumer Protection Act, 2002, SO 2002, c 30, Sch A, <https://canlii.ca/t/565k8>

[4] Bogdan, Sawyer, Global News: Crime “Hundreds defrauded in door-to-door Ontario scam, Canada wide- warrants issued”, online: global news <https://globalnews.ca/news/10764523/ontario-door-to-door-scam-3-people-wanted-canada-wide-warrents/>

[5] Gowriluk, Caitlyn, CBC Canada : Ontario women get house arrest for role in scamming Manitoba seniors out of nearly $90K, online: cbc.ca <https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/grandparent-scam-sentencing-1.7340436>