Court Rejects the Resealing of Foreign Guardianship Order – Fisher v. Danilunas
In Fisher v. Danilunas[1] 2025 ONSC 2061 (“Fisher”), the Applicants sought to enforce a foreign guardianship order obtained in England deeming Ms. Danilunas, incapable of managing her Property (the “English Order”). The Applicants requested of the ONSC, an order recognizing the English Order to assist Ms. Danilunas with the management of her assets located in Ontario.
The court found that there was a lack of case law and an insufficient statutory framework to support the granting of foreign guardianship orders in Ontario.
The Facts
On September 14, 2023, Mr. Fisher and the brother of Ms. Danilunas, Mr. Danilunas (the “Applicants”) obtained an Order in the United Kingdon, in their capacity as her “Deputies”.
In the United Kingdom, the Court describes a deputy as a “person of the Court of Protection” who is appointed to make decisions on behalf of an individual who is no longer capable to make their own decisions.[2]
The English Order provided the Applicants, as Ms. Danilunas’ deputies, the power to make decisions on her behalf, regarding her property on the basis that Ms. Danilunas suffers from Alzheimer’s Dementia as well as delusions. As a result, Ms. Danilunas was deemed incapable of managing her property as of September 12, 2023.
In their Application before the Ontario court, the Applicants requested that the Ontario court enforce the English Order, therefore appointing them as Deputies jointly and severally or in the alternative, as Ms. Danilunas’ guardians under the Substitute Decisions Act, 1992 SO 1992, C 30 (the “SDA”).
The court found that it was not possible to make “a finding that the autonomy and integrity of Ms. Danilunas is respected under the applicable foreign law as it would be [in Ontario]”.[3]
The court noted that the SDA recognizes foreign guardianship orders if the foreign jurisdiction is prescribed by the government within a regulation. Please find section 86 (2), below:
86(2) The order was made in another province or territory of Canada, or the order was made in any other jurisdiction prescribed by the government of Ontario (SO 1992, c 30 at s 86(2)). [emphasis added].
Unfortunately, the government has failed to articulate specific jurisdictions, as the Court in Fisher discusses. On this basis, the Public Guardian and Trustee objected to the Applicant’s framing of this Application as being supported by the SDA.
Despite the ambiguity of s.86 of the SDA, the Applicants contended that they should be entitled to the granting of their Guardianship Application based on common law rather than statutory law.
Analysis
The court denied the Applicants’ appointments as guardians on the basis that there were insufficient means on a statutory and common law basis to support their appointment.
Common law approach
The court denied the Applicants the relief they requested on their common law approach, noting that there was a scarcity of decisions regarding the enforcement of foreign guardianship judgements. The court noted the distinction between the enforcement of orders in rem versus in personam.
In Rem refers to an order that impacts an action against things, such as the “the incapacitated person’s status in all things”.[4] Whereas in personam refers to an action against a person. The court asserted that case law specifically lacked judgments of foreign capacity orders in rem. This is important because the enforcement of orders in rem versus in personam differ.[5]
The Court addressed several decisions submitted by counsel for the Applicant from which the Court drew questions. Such questions included dealing with concerns of public policy and allowing the enforceability of foreign judgments. The court stated the following;
“if, hypothetically, a foreign judgment declared a person to lack capacity because a close relative merely asserted a right under local law to control the affairs of another whom our law would view as having full capacity? Might it matter if the target was a person whom we would view as being vulnerable to subjugation due to an immutable factor such as race, sex, or sexual orientation etc.? Should we enforce such a judgment and, if not, on what basis would or could our law refuse to do so?”[6]
The court also commented on the government’s failure to prescribe jurisdiction under s. 86 of the SDA. The court noted the following:
“Absent evidence, I am not prepared to criticize the government for failing to prescribe any foreign jurisdiction by regulation so as to entitle capacity orders from those places to automatic recognition. Perhaps the government has yet to be convinced that there are other jurisdictions with procedural and substantive laws sufficiently similar to ours to justify that type of summary recognition.”[7]
The court requested members of the Estates bar to consider if they are able to assist the court in this matter.
Fisher v. Danilunas highlights the importance of the government’s need to address the legislative gap found within s.86 of the SDA, in order to adequately rule on the resealing of foreign guardianship applications.
For more information on resealing of foreign guardianship, see WEL Paper’s: Recognition of Foreign Guardianship Orders in Ontario Addressing the Legislative GAP.
—
[1] Fisher v. Danilunas, 2025 ONSC 2061 [“Fisher”]
[2] Fisher at para 5
[3] Fisher at para 11
[4] Fisher at para 16
[5] Fisher at para 17
[6] Fisher at para 5
[7] Fisher at para 13
Written by: Gabriella Banhara
Posted on: April 14, 2025
Categories: Commentary
In Fisher v. Danilunas[1] 2025 ONSC 2061 (“Fisher”), the Applicants sought to enforce a foreign guardianship order obtained in England deeming Ms. Danilunas, incapable of managing her Property (the “English Order”). The Applicants requested of the ONSC, an order recognizing the English Order to assist Ms. Danilunas with the management of her assets located in Ontario.
The court found that there was a lack of case law and an insufficient statutory framework to support the granting of foreign guardianship orders in Ontario.
The Facts
On September 14, 2023, Mr. Fisher and the brother of Ms. Danilunas, Mr. Danilunas (the “Applicants”) obtained an Order in the United Kingdon, in their capacity as her “Deputies”.
In the United Kingdom, the Court describes a deputy as a “person of the Court of Protection” who is appointed to make decisions on behalf of an individual who is no longer capable to make their own decisions.[2]
The English Order provided the Applicants, as Ms. Danilunas’ deputies, the power to make decisions on her behalf, regarding her property on the basis that Ms. Danilunas suffers from Alzheimer’s Dementia as well as delusions. As a result, Ms. Danilunas was deemed incapable of managing her property as of September 12, 2023.
In their Application before the Ontario court, the Applicants requested that the Ontario court enforce the English Order, therefore appointing them as Deputies jointly and severally or in the alternative, as Ms. Danilunas’ guardians under the Substitute Decisions Act, 1992 SO 1992, C 30 (the “SDA”).
The court found that it was not possible to make “a finding that the autonomy and integrity of Ms. Danilunas is respected under the applicable foreign law as it would be [in Ontario]”.[3]
The court noted that the SDA recognizes foreign guardianship orders if the foreign jurisdiction is prescribed by the government within a regulation. Please find section 86 (2), below:
86(2) The order was made in another province or territory of Canada, or the order was made in any other jurisdiction prescribed by the government of Ontario (SO 1992, c 30 at s 86(2)). [emphasis added].
Unfortunately, the government has failed to articulate specific jurisdictions, as the Court in Fisher discusses. On this basis, the Public Guardian and Trustee objected to the Applicant’s framing of this Application as being supported by the SDA.
Despite the ambiguity of s.86 of the SDA, the Applicants contended that they should be entitled to the granting of their Guardianship Application based on common law rather than statutory law.
Analysis
The court denied the Applicants’ appointments as guardians on the basis that there were insufficient means on a statutory and common law basis to support their appointment.
Common law approach
The court denied the Applicants the relief they requested on their common law approach, noting that there was a scarcity of decisions regarding the enforcement of foreign guardianship judgements. The court noted the distinction between the enforcement of orders in rem versus in personam.
In Rem refers to an order that impacts an action against things, such as the “the incapacitated person’s status in all things”.[4] Whereas in personam refers to an action against a person. The court asserted that case law specifically lacked judgments of foreign capacity orders in rem. This is important because the enforcement of orders in rem versus in personam differ.[5]
The Court addressed several decisions submitted by counsel for the Applicant from which the Court drew questions. Such questions included dealing with concerns of public policy and allowing the enforceability of foreign judgments. The court stated the following;
“if, hypothetically, a foreign judgment declared a person to lack capacity because a close relative merely asserted a right under local law to control the affairs of another whom our law would view as having full capacity? Might it matter if the target was a person whom we would view as being vulnerable to subjugation due to an immutable factor such as race, sex, or sexual orientation etc.? Should we enforce such a judgment and, if not, on what basis would or could our law refuse to do so?”[6]
The court also commented on the government’s failure to prescribe jurisdiction under s. 86 of the SDA. The court noted the following:
“Absent evidence, I am not prepared to criticize the government for failing to prescribe any foreign jurisdiction by regulation so as to entitle capacity orders from those places to automatic recognition. Perhaps the government has yet to be convinced that there are other jurisdictions with procedural and substantive laws sufficiently similar to ours to justify that type of summary recognition.”[7]
The court requested members of the Estates bar to consider if they are able to assist the court in this matter.
Fisher v. Danilunas highlights the importance of the government’s need to address the legislative gap found within s.86 of the SDA, in order to adequately rule on the resealing of foreign guardianship applications.
For more information on resealing of foreign guardianship, see WEL Paper’s: Recognition of Foreign Guardianship Orders in Ontario Addressing the Legislative GAP.
—
[1] Fisher v. Danilunas, 2025 ONSC 2061 [“Fisher”]
[2] Fisher at para 5
[3] Fisher at para 11
[4] Fisher at para 16
[5] Fisher at para 17
[6] Fisher at para 5
[7] Fisher at para 13
Author