Feature Pages ⏷

45 St. Clair Ave. West, Suite 600,
Toronto, Ontario, M4V 1K9
Tel: (416) 925-7400

The Question of a Vested ‘Zombie’ Land Transfer

Justice Myers had more questions than answers for the Estate of Laura Jeanne Helwig.[1] Under somewhat novel circumstances, the Estate was applying for an order vesting the title of a property in the name of Ms. Helwig’s nephew.

Ms. Helwig passed away of natural causes on March 3, 2025, at the age of 71.[2] The afternoon before her death, Ms. Helwig signed documents transferring the title of a property to herself and her nephew, jointly.[3] Ms. Helwig passed away before the documents were registered the next morning.[4]

A policy at the Land Registry Office has created a sticky situation for Ms. Helwig’s Estate. Since Ms. Helwig was deceased when the documents were registered, the Land Registry Office considers this a “zombie” deed.

What is a zombie deed?

A zombie deed refers to a transfer of an interest in land that is registered after the death of the grantor, as if the grantor were still alive.[5] The term ‘zombie deed’ may be synonymous with the term ‘Winarski transfer.’[6] As jurisprudence develops, Winarski may evolve to more specifically describe the sub-category of deed/transfers filed after death, where the delayed registration was the lawyer’s error.

A key example of a zombie deed/transfer can be seen in, Thompson v. Elliott Estate. In Thompson, a law firm accidentally did not file a signed transfer with the Land Registry Office. The firm did not discover their mistake until after their client’s death. The firm attempted to register this “zombie” transfer and were unsuccessful. The court ultimately issued a vesting order, instead.

If a zombie deed/transfer is discovered by the Land Registry Office, it will be rejected.[7] However, the Ontario Court of Justice has noted that some lawyers have used zombie deeds/transfers to try and avoid probate taxes and fees.[8]

How zombie deeds have been dealt with

The Land Registry Office rejects zombie deeds because they do not comply with the Government of Ontario’s registration regulations and requirements for electronic registration systems used by lawyers for land transfers in Ontario.[9] The Ontario Superior Court of Justice has found that registering a zombie deed is improper, as it involves making false statements to the Land Registry Office.[10]

Caselaw says that applying for a court order is an appropriate solution, allowed for by the Land Titles Act.[11]  Thompson has been interpreted to mean that beneficiaries must apply to the court for a declaration of an interest in land, showing that the deed was delivered but retained by counsel due to inadvertence or some other legitimate reason.[12] If a lawyer discovers an error post-registration, the proper procedure is to request a certificate of pending litigation and a declaration of interest in land from the Superior Court of Ontario.[13]

Why Ms. Helwig’s Estate does not yet have a Court Order

Precedent from higher court(s) supersedes precedents from courts on the same level of the judicial hierarchy. In other words, Myers J., must follow precedents from the Ontario Court of appeal and other higher courts, even if it goes against jurisprudence from other Ontario Superior Court decisions. The Thompson case, which took place in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, indicates that it is an appropriate solution for the court to vest title to Ms. Helwig’s nephew. However, Justice Myers opined that jurisprudence from the Ontario Court of Appeal rules out that option. Hooper v Hooper and other jurisprudence hold that title passes from transferor to transferee when the deed is signed and delivered, even if the registration occurs later.[14]

Myers J., has ruled out Thompson’s approach for Ms. Helwig’s Estate, based on the facts that were before him on April 30, 2025. Now, the next steps are a big question mark. Even the appropriate title for the proceeding is uncertain.[15] Myers J., has a lot of outstanding questions for the representatives of Ms. Helwig’s Estate:

  • Can the estate trustees not complete the registration on behalf of the vendor? Is it only a problem with e-registration? Is paper still allowed?
  • Can a personal representative not sign a Land Transfer Tax Statement on behalf of a vendor?
  • How do people under disability convey property but through powers of attorney or personal representatives?
  • Does the undisclosed “policy statement” or the whatever law, regulation, or executive edict that creates the templates for land transfer tax forms prohibit minor alterations to wording to ensure that the substance of the contents is true?
  • If e-registration cannot handle form changes, how do representatives for vendors register transfers? Why can that not be done here?
  • Should the estate of the vendor be the applicant, or should the current owner be the applicant? If he is not an applicant, shouldn’t the owner/nephew be a party respondent since the relief sought is an order vesting title to the property in him?
  • Should the Director of Titles be a party? Should he be served regardless?
  • If this is a request for mandamus, is it the right type of proceeding in the right court?[16]

Some of Justice Myer’s questions are easier to answer than others. Now more than ever, as the case law in Ontario develops, it may be prudent to avoid ‘zombie’ deeds.

—

[1] Estate of Laura Jeanne Helwig, Deceased, 2025 ONSC 2661 (CanLII), <https://canlii.ca/t/kbwgf>

[2] “Obituary information for Laura Helwig”, online: <https://www.reidfuneralhome.ca/obituaries/obituary-listings?obId=39238906>.

[3] Estate of Laura Jeanne Helwig, supra note 1 at para 9.

[4] Ibid.

[5] Thompson v. Elliott Estate, 2020 ONSC 1004 (CanLII), <https://canlii.ca/t/j5rnj>, at para 2; Lamont on Real Estate Conveyancing 2nd, “Joint Tenants and Tenants in Common—Joint Tenancy” at§ 6:4 (May 2025).

[6] see Thompson v. Elliott Estate, supra note 5 at para 12.

[7] Ibid at para 34.

[8] Ibid at para 35.

[9] CED 4th, Real Property (Ontario), “XIV. Land Titles Act: Registration of Land Under Act” at § 146 (February 2025); Thompson v. Elliott Estate, supra note 5 at paras 27, 89.

[10] Thompson v. Elliott Estate, supra note 5 at paras 28, 37, 67.

[11] “Land Titles Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. L.5 | ontario.ca”, s 25, online: <https://www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/90l05>; Thompson v. Elliott Estate, supra note 5 at para 90.

[12] CED 4th, Tax Planned Will Precedents, “Part II Expositive Clauses—Commentary and Alternate Clauses For Essential Elements of the Will: Severance of Joint Tenancy” at § 2:107.

[13] Ibid; Thompson v. Elliott Estate, supra note 5 at para 11.

[14] Hooper v. Hooper, 1953 CanLII 361 (ON CA), <https://canlii.ca/t/gwcpv>, at 447; Estate of Laura Jeanne Helwig, supra note 1 at para 5.

[15] Estate of Laura Jeanne Helwig, supra note 1 at para 23.

[16]Ibid at paras 15, 23.

Author

Previous Post:
Next Post:
Click here or on top Blog logo to return to Blog front page.

Search Blog by Keyword(s)

Site Search

Site Map