Feature Pages ⏷

45 St. Clair Ave. West, Suite 600,
Toronto, Ontario, M4V 1K9
Tel: (416) 925-7400

An Applicant’s Abuse of Process and Invalidating an Annulment Contract: Zant v Zant

In Zant v. Zant, 2022 BCSC 2023[1] (“Zant”), the Court addressed a host of issues regarding Mr. Zant’s (the “Applicant”) applications and counter applications to the Supreme Court of British Columbia (the “Court”), including his abuse of process. This blog will focus on the Application that was filed on March 2, 2022, to set aside the annulment of the Applicant and Gina Zant’s (the “Respondent”) marriage (the “Annulment Order”).

The Applicant and the Respondent were married in 1999 in the Cook Islands and on March 16, 2016, they were separated. The Applicant received pension benefits under the Operating Engineer’s Pension Plan (the “Pension Plan”). As a result of the Applicant’s and Respondents’ marriage, the Respondent was entitled to an interest in the Applicant’s Pension Plan.

On November 3, 2021, the Applicant filed a notice of Application (the “Annulment Application”) seeking an order, amongst other things, that the Respondent was removed as a beneficiary to the Applicant’s Pension Plan and that their marriage was annulled. The Applicant contended that his marriage to the Respondent in the Cook Islands was null and void on the basis that she had not divorced her previous husband, Robert John (“Mr. R”).

In the Respondent’s Responding Application, she consented to all orders requested by the Applicant and provided the following statements:

[13] I was fully aware that our marriage in the Cook Islands [was] not legally binding, I took the decision not to tell Warren. I did not want to explain that I am still legally married to Mr. Hovey. The claimant never asked for my divorce documents and believed everything I told him. The claimant is correct, I signed myself as beneficiary onto all his pension plans and benefits plans.

I signed his name on the documents and witnessed the paperwork myself, I was employed in the pension plan and benefits office of local 115 at the time. At the time of signing the paperwork, we were not legally married, I was and still am married to Mr. Hovey and the claimant and myself were not living together for more than 2 years. [Therefore] I have no legal rights to his pensions and benefits. [2]

Notably, on November 24, 2021, the Applicant and the Respondent appeared before Justice Hori on Zoom, where individuals identified as the Applicant and Respondent submitted a consent order bearing their signatures (the “November 2021 Hearing”).

On January 11, 2022, the Pension Plan received a copy of the Annulment Order from the Applicant and contacted the Respondent to inform her of the Annulment Order. The Applicant surprisingly, informed the Pension Plan administrator that she had not been aware of any Court proceedings involving her, she did not sign a Court order, and she was not present during the November 2021 Hearing. As a result, the Pension Plan brought an application, seeking to set aside the Annulment Order “on the basis that it was obtained by an abuse of process, fraud and perjury, or a deliberate attempt to mislead the Court”.[3]

The Applicant and the Respondent appeared before the Court on the Annulment Application on several occasions, seeking adjournments and delays. The various adjournments spanned over 6 months, during which the Applicant filed various counter applications, which formed a part of 109-page requisition to have his applications heard without notice. The Court denied the Applicant this relief. The Applicant sought the following in his counter applications:[4]

  1. An order removing Justice Hori as the presiding judge on the matter and transferring the case to the Salmon Arm Registry

The Applicant failed to assert any factual basis for Justice Hori’s removal as the presiding judge and on this basis the Court dismissed this application.

The Applicant asserted that he wanted to transfer his file to the Salmon Registry because the Kamloops Court Registry (the “Registry”) was repeatedly rejecting his filings because he did not follow the Registry’s filing procedures. The Court dismissed this request because the Court was agreeable with the Registry. In addition, the Court stated that regardless of filing procedures, the “rejection of documents” is not sufficient to change the venue of a proceeding.[5]

Lack of Credibility 

The Court provided over five pages of examples to demonstrate the Applicant’s lack of credibility. In the Applicant’s Affidavit Exhibits a copy of an email sent from the Senior registry manager of the Cook Islands was included. The email stated that a marriage certificate did not exist between the Applicant and the Respondent on the basis that it was fraudulent and void.[6] The origin of the email was not provided by the Applicant.

In response, the Respondent provided a copy of a different email to the Cook Islands Registry who stated that the Applicant’s Affidavit exhibits were fraudulent, as they were not signed by the Cook Islands registry. The Court asserted that the Respondent’s evidence called into question the authenticity of the Applicant’s evidence regarding the Annulment Order.

The Court went on to state that through the various examples of evidence and representations brought forward by the Applicant, it was clear that he, nor his representatives were credible. In addition, the Applicant was deemed to be making “allegations that suit their purposes at that time without regard to the validity of those allegations”. [7] On this basis the Court stated they could not provide any weight to the representations made by the Applicant.

Setting aside the Annulment Order

The Pension Plan sought to set aside the Annulment Order pursuant to s.200(2) of the Family Law Act S.B.C. 2011, c.25 (the “FLA”) which provides as follows:

2) If an order was made in the absence of a party, the court, in accordance with the Supreme Court Family Rules or the Provincial Court Family Rules, as applicable, may change, suspend or set aside the order.[8]

The Respondent asserted that she was not present in Court during the November 2021 Hearing, and the Applicant had obtained an impersonator to attend on the Respondents behalf. In addition, the Respondent provided a valid divorce certificate, demonstrating that she was divorced at the time of her marriage to the Applicant.

On this basis, the Court found in favour of the Respondent and set aside the Annulment Order pursuant to S.200(2) of the FLA. The Court determined that there was in fact an impersonator posing as the Respondent during the November 2021 Hearing and the Respondent was legally married to the Applicant in 1999 in the Cook Islands.

The Court asserted it had inherent jurisdiction “to set aside a consent order where there are grounds that would invalidate a contract.”[9] The Respondent did not consent to the Annulment Order on the November 2021 Hearing, rather, her imposter did, therefore demonstrating that an agreement never existed amongst the Applicant and the Respondent in the first place.

Abuse of Process

Additionally, the Court asserted that the Annulment order may be set aside on the basis that it constitutes an abuse of process and a miscarriage of justice. The court went on to state:

[94] There should be no question that it is an abuse of process for a party to secure an order of the court with the assistance of an imposter.[10]

It would be against the interest of justice to allow the Annulment Order to be in force when the Respondent failed to consent to the terms of the Order. [11]

In Zant, the Court addressed significant procedural and substantive issues, ultimately setting aside the Annulment Order due to the Applicant’s abuse of process and lack of credibility. The Court’s decision underscores the importance of integrity in legal proceedings and the Court’s willingness to exercise its inherent jurisdiction to rectify abuses of process and ensure justice has been upheld.

—

[1] Zant v Zant, 2022 BCSC 2023 (“Zant)”

[2] Zant at para 13

[3] Zant at para 18

[4] Zant at para 27

[5] Zant at para 45

[6] Zant at para 52

[7] Zant at para 65

[8] Zant at para 77

[9] Zant at para 93

[10] Zant at para 94

[11] Ibid at para 94

Author

Previous Post:
Next Post:
Click here or on top Blog logo to return to Blog front page.

Search Blog by Keyword(s)

Site Search

Site Map